Cars! (1947-2021)

My aunt Edith H. Church in her 1923 Dodge touring car, with Edith Horton and Becky Harris.


Twice to the Moon and Back:
A Reminiscence Upon Having Given Up Driving


Sometime in the early seventies, on the long way back from somewhere; during a child-crushing passage of boredom, the children asked: “Daddy, how far have you driven?” After some mental deliberation involving imperfect memory and some suspect arithmetic I announced: “Well, I’m about halfway back from the moon.”


It has been said of the Allied Victory in World War II that credit was due the mechanical skill and know-how of men who had grown up in close proximity to the farm contraptions and the jalopies of their boyhoods. They seemed to have an edge over enemy troops in the business of keeping the engines and wheels of their heroic efforts in motion. 

How then could we imagine that our grandchildren—in two generations—would never know the joy, the pain, the frustration, and the grimy knuckle-busting satisfactions of working on cars? I think that the success and the pervasiveness of the age of technology and of social media has robbed them of something essential. To be fair, though—the modern car is virtually impossible to comprehend. Unless one is a professional mechanic, trained in technical school, or in a modern shop, today’s kid has scant possibility, or even an interest in, an activity as remote from today’s skittering thumbs as can be imagined: the delights and miseries of futzing about with cars.


1947-1948

In 1947 I paid ninety-five dollars for a 1925 Nash four-door straight-eight sedan, best described as the typical gangster car of Al Capone’s Chicago. It was my age (22) and might have seen 150,000 miles. It had a spare tire on each running board, a luggage rack in back, dual ignition (sixteen spark-plugs!), and, having no starter motor: crank to start.

I parked it in a small space near the house. I was shy about discussing cars with my father knowing that a serious lecture on responsibility would have to be endured. Better just to buy one. Several days later he asked me, “Do you know whose car that is out there in front?”

Cranking required a throttle lever on the steering column and another to advance and retard the ignition (spark) timing. Throttle advancement ensured that the engine, once started, would be “revved” up a bit, and retarded timing—delaying the spark from its running position before cylinder top-dead-center—prevented early firing from unexpectedly snapping the crank backwards. Many a thumb or forearm had thus been broken. The Nash ran reliably but poorly, generating clouds of blue smoke indicating the excessive burning of oil.

And, so, my adventure began—with a ring and valve job. I was handy with tools; knew something in principle about engines, had flown B29 combat missions as a radar navigator in the Pacific in 1945; but little in detail about cars. Access to the valves required the removal of the engine’s cast iron “head,” but new piston rings were more of a challenge—requiring oil pan removal, dissembling the rod bearings from the crank-shaft, and pushing the pistons up and out of the cylinders. I found that I needed mysterious special tools of which I had never heard—valve-spring lifters, ring compressors, torque and tappet wrenches, and ridge reamers.

Our schoolroom was the local auto parts store and our teachers the intimidating men behind the counter who treated us, at first, as though our trade was hardly worth the instructional hassle required. We found obtaining special tools especially daunting owing to the embarrassment of having to reveal not only our ignorance, but that, in our penury, we couldn’t afford them. But gradually rapport was forged allowing us occasionally to borrow what we needed, provided we guaranteed—by bicycle—a timely return. Gradually we became more and more the beneficiaries of useful and friendly advice.

My job was straightforward with one exception: an exhaust valve so badly burned that simple regrinding could not save it. A wide tour of the auto junk yards of Greater Boston proved fruitless and so I was stuck unless… unless I could make one of my own. That summer I had a job at Northeastern University as an assistant in the mechanical engineering laboratory running the various engines and test equipment for the students. One job was the making of steel tensile test specimens, and so I learned how operate a metal turning lathe.

Exhaust valve
Exhaust valve

Exhaust valves must be of high-temperature resistant steel. Figuring that truck valves might, in general, be bigger than car valves I went to the parts desk at the Reo dealership, put my valve on the counter, and asked whether an exhaust valve could be found with my valve “inside” it. Once the counter man got the idea he produced several and with my ruler and micrometer we soon found one. On the lathe I turned down the shaft and head, cut the required grooves and bevels, and “ground it in” with the others where it served for the rest of the life of the car.


1948-1950

The Nash “threw a rod” and died on the famous hills of the Cornell University campus; succeeded by a 1934 Pontiac business coupe bought from a fraternity brother. I brush-painted it blue. It had four-on-the-floor—on a trip to New York City spattering dark transmission oil on the nylon hose of my unhappy passenger. At the fraternity house one night that spring I had a visit from the Campus Police who wanted an explanation for its having been found upside down in a major campus intersection. Two men and a woman had been seen leaving the scene. I never found the culprits though they were undoubtedly among my “brothers.”

Ithaca winters were snowy. Before snow tires we had chains, a lattice of links draped over the rear tires and fastened—with freezing fingers—by awkward hooks, all the while on your back in the snow. Inevitably they developed loose ends to flail against the inside of the fender. The bang, bang, bang of loose chain ends in the cold air is one of the lost sounds of winter.


1950-1952

Upon leaving Cornell at graduation I gave up the Pontiac for a 1939 Studebaker Champion business coupe—gradually the model years were approaching the present. I had this nice car for several of my early years in New York City. It was the same age as the Pontiac we had in France in 1939. I have a memory of “doing” the brakes—or maybe it was the universal joints—while parked on a side street on Manhattan’s upper West Side.

In the winter of 1952 I quit my job at Kearfott in Newark and, to my father’s alarm, became a ski-bum at Stowe, Vermont for three months. My job at the Stowaway Inn kept me in shelter and food; as an auxiliary on the ski patrol my lift tickets were free; my only expenses being cigarettes and gas for the Studebaker.

I have forgotten to what malaise it ultimately succumbed.


1952-1953

I had always a yen for an antique car. An urge finally satisfied by getting a 1929 Model-A Ford from an old guy in the Bronx. It was a convertible roadster with a rumble seat and, yes, crank to start.

It needed a new clutch. Serendipity had it that where I had lived on Barrow Street at 6th Avenue was a tiny gas station where I sort of knew the proprietor from having parked the Studebaker there. He let me do the clutch job practically on the sidewalk.

Later I lived on Waverly Place. A subsequent valve and rig job took several days with two wheels on the sidewalk in the midst of an al fresco art exhibit.

I drove to Boston that summer with a girlfriend. Coming back down a long hill on the Wilbur Cross Parkway in Wallingford, Conn. the timing belt broke. We had to be towed and took the bus to New York. I always note that spot whenever driving between Boston and New York City.

Late that fall I drove it to Toms River, New Jersey to winter over at my sister Holley’s.

Sadly, in the spring I was T-boned by a couple running a red light on Second Avenue. They fled the scene with a leaking radiator; nobody had taken their number so I followed the water trail as far as I could until I lost it. The frame was bent beyond reasonable repair and I had to junk it.

To this day I have a recurring dream that I’m in my Model-A driving merrily along.


1953-1956

By now I was working on the Plaza at 58th Street in Henry Dreyfuss’ famous industrial design office. I became friends with an interesting man, Roland Stickney, who made beautiful and detailed renderings with colored pencils and tempera for presentation to clients of the various products that we were working on. In a previous life he was famous for renderings of the body designs of classic cars for the clients of custom carriage work designers. We had a mutual interest in cars and wasted lots of time talking about them. To replace the Model-A he suggested that I look into getting a small Canadian 1950 model called the Morris Oxford. I did and it became known among my friends as “Morrie the Ox”.

With a homemade rack on top Morrie made many winter trips to the ski country in Vermont, often as far as Stowe where I had been a ski-bum in the winter of 1952. And it made summer weekend camping trips to nearby State Parks.

Note the slot between the doors. Before hand gestures and blinking turn signals cars—especially foreign ones—had lighted “idiot sticks” that flicked out like finger posts.

Morrie gradually sickened and reached a point where a broken tooth gap in the flywheel too often stopped just at the point where it was needed next to engage the starter pinion. That meant to start you had to push it in gear to reposition the flywheel. It was by pure luck that it started for the buyer to whom I sold it—I yet feel a small pang of guilt when I recall this episode.


1956-1959

Enter my first brand new car: a 1957 VW Beetle. Roland had convinced me that the best thing I could do was to buy a Beetle. It was in this car that I first set eyes on the cliffs at New Paltz in September 1956, and two years later that Crissy and I set off on a trip to Maine.

Beetles then were still sufficiently rare that one honked and blinked at passing brethren. Its one odd failing was occasional fatal carburetor icing—a problem unique to airplanes—on cold damp days.

While slowing down it had to be double-clutched into first, although brave aficionados claimed that this was not really necessary. It was a sprightly beast and I loved it.

In the summer of 1958, driving home somewhere north of Ellsworth, Maine, Crissy and I had a near fatal single-car crash wherein the right front wheel dug in to a soft shoulder and catapulted us into the air. We landed on the left rear roof and miraculously rolled back onto the wheels. When the dust had settled I found myself in the back seat with a broken tooth, and Crissy sitting on the pavement, her arms reaching up to and still clutching the steering wheel. We were totally shaken but essentially uninjured.

No police showed up. Gradually the curious onlookers dissipated leaving us alone.

The car needed attention. The right front wheel was bent both inwardly canted and pigeon-toed. The windshield was crazed, the roof bashed in, and the rear window popped halfway out—like the bow-tie askew on a dissolute reveler. There was a gas station within considerable walking distance so it wasn’t long before I had the flat fixed and the wonky wheel remounted.

It seemed that with some futzing around we might be able to drive it. It proved a tedious process: jack up the wheel, turn the adjustment nut extending the length of the steering tie-rod, jack back down, test drive a few feet, repeat. Eventually we got it—no-hands—to track straight, though seriously knock-kneed, and cautiously struck off for New York. The driver’s side door had to be tied shut and the pressure on the crazed windshield bowed it in alarmingly so we wedged a stick inside for support.

We limped along to spend that night in Wellesley, concealing the bashed side of the car from fatherly view. At the VW place once safely back in the city the service manager, clipboard in hand, took one look and shouted, “Hey fellas, come take a look at this one!” Amazingly, it was repaired. I kept it that year but it was clear that all was not well and the time had come for change.


1959-1961

The new Bug, a 1959, was black, had a bigger rear-view window, and a fuel gauge—this last, a sign of the smug American dismissal of practical German asceticism.

Of course, immediately I bought lap-belt kits and installed them in the front seats. [For sixty-two years since then I have never driven an un-belted mile.] Three-point belts—too hard to install from kits—arrived after 1959, and were not mandatory until 1966. In later years I was amazed to pass jacked-up pickup trucks, equipped with ostentatious roll-bars, and driven by un-belted jocks expressing their American Exceptionalism. Freedumb!

By then we had our daughter Holley who, with her paraphernalia, took over the back seat on vacation trips and to the family’s summer retreat in Connecticut.

As yet, unforeseen, this car’s demise was already written in the stars.


1961-1968

We had twins!

We bought a new black 1960 Ford Econoline van. In 1963 it saw us through our big move from New York City to Line Street in Somerville, my trip to the eclipse of 1963 in Maine, and then to the new old house in Weston, Mass.

Years later one morning after much cranking and choking the car failed to start. The fuel pump had died. So how was I to get to the service place? Towing was expensive so the miser in me came to the fore. I found an orange juice can and a short stub of copper tube which I soldered to a hole punched in its bottom. A length of rubber tubing with an adjustable lab clamp completed the assembly. With the air cleaner off I supported my fuel filled gadget over the open carburetor air intake and by fine tuning the drip I could get the engine to run in fits and starts and made it haltingly to the garage.

It was in this van that, on my fortieth birthday in January 1965, we ran out of gas on the thruway in New Hampshire on the way back from a diversionary ski trip in support of a surprise party planned by Crissy and the children—before cellphones! Ponder that, ye moderns.


1968-1977

Next a new, green 1970 Dodge Tradesman van. I have no recollection as to why we switched from Ford to Dodge. It had what became, in the car world, a famous engine—the “Slant Six.”

Over the years this car made many trips to climbing at the ‘Gunks, to the family’s Windrush, and to the North Country in summer and winter. It wasn’t set up for camping but by laying cupboard doors across the tops of the reversed middle and rear seat we could uncomfortably sleep four with sleeping bags on air mattresses. We passed one miserable, well below zero night in a parking lot at Stowe that the children have not forgotten.

No one anymore worries about not starting in below zero weather. No one anymore puts the battery in the kitchen sink in warm water overnight. No one’s radiator freezes. No one anymore carries a spray can of starting ether—with the air cleaner off, squirting into the carburetor—a good way to start an engine fire.

I spent endless hours over its nine-year life replacing the driveshaft universal joints, doing the brakes, and replacing spark plugs and fan belts. On at least four occasions we had to replace the alternator on the road—so often that I learned never to travel without a spare under the passenger seat.

Later the throttle butterfly would stick closed preventing starting. The engine cover and the air cleaner had to be laboriously removed in order to tap it free. Eventually I drilled a hole all the way through both cover and cleaner to accommodate a stiff wire that could reach the butterfly. [See Comments below for a remembrance of this stick by my old friend Steve Angelini.]

It was in this car that we were driving home from Connecticut on the Mass Pike on the day of the moon landing in July 1969. During the final crucial seconds every car, almost in unison, pulled onto the shoulder to await the fateful words: “Houston, the Eagle has landed.” In bitter retrospect, that was when America was great.

“eclipse, wE MADe It!”

And in 1970 the twins and I went to Nantucket Airport to photograph the flash spectrum of the solar chromosphere at the total eclipse of 1970.

By 1977—separated from my family—I lived on Soden Street in Cambridge near Central Square.

During the second oil crisis of 1977 I installed an auxiliary gas tank. That winter twice, twice! while sleeping peacefully in rural New Hampshire I was awakened by a slight rocking and by gurgling sounds. Realizing someone was siphoning gas I arose stealthily, slipped into my shoes, and smartly smote the metal side of the interior. BAM! Amid clattering sounds they fled in panic.

They sought gas for their snowmobiles. In one case it was the kids next door, reprimanded and provided with a lifelong “remember the time when” story. In the other, some kid had to explain to his father: “What happened to our gas can?”

Eventually, again, I was T-boned at a snowy intersection in Allston, and this time it was my fault—sort of. The RMV wanted to penalize me, in a way that I have now forgotten, but I was allowed to make a case at an official hearing. I had a photo of the site showing snow partially obliterating the stop sign. It was enough to get me off.


1977-1988


After months of plotting advertised used van prices vs. mileage on an Excel spreadsheet I suddenly found an obvious outlier. I jumped on it, rushed to see it, and a few days later rode my bike the 25 miles to Salem to pick it up. On the way back to Cambridge a mouse emerged from the air vent and clung desperately to a windshield wiper before being swept away.

It was a maroon 1974 Dodge Tradesman needing DIY work for camping: side door windows, roof vent, rear seat belts, sleeping deck cum rear seat conversion, curtains, bug netting, etc. Almost immediately someone stole the battery from the Soden Street parking lot but after that it made uncountable trips to the ‘Gunks, to the rivers of New Hampshire and Maine, climbing in West Virginia, and beyond—all the while we listened endlessly to the McGarrigle Sisters, The Hitch-Hiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, the Beatles, and my burgeoning collection of classical tapes.

In 1980 I moved again for two years to Concord, and eventually back to the old house in Weston.

Seven years later the first of two disasters struck. A broken timing chain stranded me on Route 9 at a ramp causing an embarrassing tie-up. Adding insult to injury a passing truck tore off my side-view mirror.

The engine had to be rebuilt. I no longer had the time and the will to do it myself. It took $2,500 and three weeks during which time I rode my recumbent bike the twelve miles to Boston every day, sometimes stopping at the Waltham body shop on the way home to check on progress.

Then in 1988 I parked it one night in front of my daughter Holley’s apartment on Clinton Street in Cobble Hill, Brooklyn. I had removed most items of value, including my bike and, as a precaution, the distributor rotor. In the morning the van was gone! The thieves had towed it! I lost all my tools. The real bummer, though, was the loss of my music tapes—I never replaced them; I miss them to this day.


1988-1991

Just then, as luck would have it, some friends of friends were selling a Dodge 1980 Aspen wagon. It had the famous Slant Six engine with which I was familiar and so I bought it almost sight unseen. Two could comfortably crash in the back; it would do until something better came along. It was my first with automatic transmission and power steering.

I gave it up three years later when that same automatic transmission went south.


1991-2005

After hours of study and measurement in the dealer’s lot I decided on a new 1990 Dodge Caravan. It was to serve as a camper as well as a passenger car so I had to be sure I could engineer a conversion without removing the rear seat. In order to sleep two and to provide for cargo I needed a removable deck in back integrated with the folded seat. The result was a pretty good kludge that often drew admiration.

A roof vent, curtains, mosquito netting, etc. completed the work. The foam pads could be folded away. The deck had two leaves; the rear most, when turned over, became a table for cooking. With a new 2×3 pine rack I could secure two canoes, kayaks, or bicycles on top. It was not as commodious as the wide old Tradesman, wherein one could stretch out crosswise, but it was good enough.

After many miles the alternator failed on a Sunday in Milford Mills, New Hampshire, requiring a bus trip to Boston. It was towed to the apron of a closed garage. The next day a faithful housemate drove me all the way back so I could install a new alternator.

Early in the morning twilight at the ‘Gunks we hit a deer causing significant damage to the right front. It was weeks of relying, again, on the recumbent bike.

In the end, after fourteen years, it died, not surprisingly, of cancer of the frame.


2005-2015

I found my next Caravan at a tiny used car dealership in Somerville—a 2000 I think. It was less boxy and more curvaceous than the its predecessor, rendering the space inside less useful—an unfortunate trend that I see all around me these days. A kind of mindless dumbing-down of utility.

By chopping and bending here and there I got the previous camping amenities shoe-horned into the new volume. I never got around to adding a roof vent—open windows and insect netting would have to suffice.

There is little as exciting as—parked at a ‘Gunks scenic overlook, snug in a sleeping bag—having a raging tempest of thunder and lightning rocking you awake to the roar of rain on the roof.

Finally, sharing the genes of its predecessor, it too, succumbed to the cancer. A cancer so pervasive that there remained no solid means even of jacking the car to change a tire.  No longer could it pass a State Inspection.


2010-2015

It was instantly and shockingly obvious that I would have to replace it.

My service shop of fifty years, Regan’s Service of Auburndale, had recently begun to dabble in used cars and Pat was quick to beckon me to view his collection. He had a 2007 Subaru Outback and without hesitation flung forward half the rear seat to show me how one could sleep full length. The irony, of course, was that I knew in my secret heart that I would never again sleep in a car at any length. And I never did.

After a useful modification to the roof rack and the addition of a deck in back I added some prosthetics to make easier my finger access to the steering column [a wrist support/hand lever] and dash controls [golf tee glued to the windshield wiper stick]—dictated by the recurrence of an old shoulder injury.

You can’t really work on cars anymore and the Subaru was no exception. You can’t even change the spark plugs, let alone see them. On some new car models the parts under the hood are packed so tightly that you could roll a golf ball across the array without losing it into a crevice somewhere.

For five years all went well until a moment’s inattention steered me into a waiting telephone pole which was severed cleanly at its base while, for its part, maliciously destroying the right front suspension.


2015-2021

I replaced it with a nearly identical 2008 Outback.

One million miles. Fifteen cars in seventy-five years. That’s about five years, and sixty-seven thousand miles per car.

Ineluctably, the time had come. My son has driven it away forever. 😦


Twice to the moon and back—a journey of nearly a million miles filled with fun, adventure, misadventure, and the joy of freedom on wheels.


Header image at top of post: My aunt Edith H. Church in her 1923 Dodge touring car, with Edith Horton and Becky Harris.


I’d love to hear your own reminiscences of cars past, in the Comments below

The Quickdraw: A Climbing Vignette (1980)

Or How the Speed-clip Lost Its Mojo

The original quickdraw was the product of trad route desperation. And had nothing whatever to do with “sport” climbing—which hadn’t yet been introduced  (1983).

The next pitch looks gnarly. You see a pin up there—or a possible nut slot—but, jeez, no place to rest while clipping the piece and wrestling up a bight of rope for the final clip. Maybe there’s a quicker way—a lesson from the Old West—and so the “quickdraw” was born.

Thus, be prepared: In advance, before committing, clip one sling end to your gear loop and the other free end to the rope. Then, at the pin, it’s just one quick draw from your gear loop to the piece. No wrestling with the rope.

To illustrate how well this works I commend you to the following memory of my climbing partner of forty years—Wes Grace:

I’ve known Bill since 1970 at which time he was an icon to me. After a year or so he
deigned actually to climb with me. From that humble start our relationship grew from mentor and novice to camaraderie. It was now possible for me to make suggestions.

Some time around 1980 we walked down the carriage road. Bill was reflective and silent. Eventually he looked up and said, “You know, I’ve been thinking about leading High Exposure.  I don’t know if I am up to it, but if I wait any longer I certainly won’t do it.

Bill, I said, “You can do it.” Of course I had no idea whether he could do it or not. It
seemed the right thing to say.

The first two pitches aren’t hard. But then we were under a gigantic roof where you can see what you can’t see, the entire top pitch. You know it goes straight up and you know that once you get started you pretty much have to keep going but you can’t see. You back up to the edge, get your toes right on the edge of a 200 foot drop, reach around for a pin you can’t see, and then duck under the roof and swing out into the void holding on with your fingers jammed in the crack. Bill clipped that first pin, and then there was just Bill from the knees down—then he was gone.

The rope paid out. Then…
F**K!!!
The rope started to come back in. It came in bits and jerks and then stopped. For a long time. Then it paid out again.

I had my turn, gasping as I swung out holding on with jammed fingers, later diving into the little depression where it goes from dead vertical to easy for a few feet.
Then the top.

I, breathlessly:
Bill, what happened? In his excitement he had clipped the wrong ‘biner on his quickdraw to the second piton thus connecting his harness to the pin. He had to climb down until he could reach it, clip it to the rope and then unclip from his harness.

It wasn’t too many years later going down the same carriage road that Bill said he knew what we were going to do. We’re going to do High Exposure and YOU are going to lead it.”

Bill was good at knowing what others were going to do. On our annual trip to the west in 1999 he knew what we were going to do. A classic climb every day. Dark Shadows at Red Rocks, Mental Physics, Sail Away and Walk on the Wild Side at Joshua Tree and Cat in the Hat back at Red Rocks. And he knew I was going to lead every one.

Bill, that was a week I won’t forget. Thanks.


 

The Gendarme: A Climbing Vignette (1973-1987)

SenecaRocks001
The Gendarme

1987_SarahBill001Every few years we, in the Boston climbing group, would go for a week to Seneca Rocks in what was then the town of Mouth of Seneca, West Virginia. We would climb at the ‘Gunks on the way there and again on the way back.

As early as 1973 there was no climber’s shop—only Buck Harper’s general store and an old covered wooden
pavilion with a stage at one end and no electricity. Here was where we camped. A wildly swaying suspension bridge over the Potomac’s North Fork gave access to the Rocks.                              Sarah & Bill>>

We went again in 1980—by which time there was a new climbing store called the Gendarme—an eponymous reference to the fifty foot stone sentinel standing guard in Gunsight Notch between the north and south faces of the cliffs. On each visit it was considered obligatory to climb it.

GendarmeBut we climbed it with reservation owing to its precarious aspect, narrower at its base than in its body—more like a Popsicle than an obelisk. Topping out below it on the climb Banana one could actually see “air” through its base—the “stick” of the Popsicle—a slab of rock seemingly not more than three feet by twelve in cross section.  Over beer in the dark at the Pavilion we would speculate about the effects of the weight and motion of climbers or about how much wind it might take to de-stabilize it. We marveled over what geologic forces might have produced it and wondered about its age. The cliffs in near their present form have been there for millions of years.

1987_WireBridge001Again in 1987 I was at Seneca for a week in late September with my friend Sarah. The suspension bridge had been carried away by floods in 1985—replaced by two cables, one high and one low, for the hands overhead and the feet below. And, of course before we left, we had climbed the Gendarme.


Four weeks later at the ‘Gunks, at the end of a day of climbing, Sarah ran up to me and said:
“Guess what happened at Seneca?”

Without a moment’s hesitation I replied: “The Gendarme fell.”

And so, on October 22nd—a sunny, windless Thursday afternoon—the sentinel collapsed and, with a roar, dashed itself into thousands of shards below.

In contemplation of this event, in relation to the geologic time-scale, it seems Sarah and I had had a pretty close call.

And now for a climerick:


         Believing that sentry ill-starred,
         They crept so's to mount it un-jarred.
             No aeon knows when...
             But had it failed then
         'T would surely have caught them off guard!     Virginia West

 More climbing vignettes:
Bobo to the Rescue
Serendipity
“Travails” With Charley


The ‘Gunks of Yore: Bob Larsen (1925-2018)

Remembering Bob Larsen (1925-2018)

Sixty-two years ago, in September of 1956, I arrived at the Uberfall—a total neophyte; an Appie beginner.

That first climb! All the way to the top of the cliff on a rope led by Bob Larsen.
Wow! Who knew?

It was The Easy Overhang.

Bob led many of my early climbs; I felt that he was looking out for me. The next spring he offered my first “leg on a climb” toward becoming an Appie leader.

It was the top pitch of Baby.

We became friends. On long drives from Manhattan I learned with fascination about the Merchant Marine, the arcane social entanglements at the Uberfall, and the stirrings of a new sub-culture unfettered by convention—a culture to which Bob was an early adherent:

There was a john in the kitchen of his East Village pad. There I smoked my first joint.

Eventually, inspired by Bob’s account of his own Teton ascent, I bought a rope and went west to climb the Grand.

And so, owing to Bob’s mentorship, a door opened to the world of mountaineering;
And my life was changed forever.

Bill Atkinson, 22 September 2018


 

“Travails” with Charley: A Climbing Vignette (1972)

Dick Williams 1972 guidebook

In the early seventies I had been climbing in the ‘Gunks off and on for fifteen years and, having been a cautious venturer, had just recently been getting into leading the “sixes.” Such classics as “Disneyland,” “Middle Earth,” and “High Exposure” were behind me and so, one day with Sam Tatnall in 1973, we happened upon “Travels with Charley”—a 5.6 in Dick Williams’ 1972 guidebook.

The left-facing corner on the first pitch seemed hard—and perhaps that should have told us something. However, I made it safely to the belay and brought up Sam.

The next pitch was steep and ended in a rising traverse up right, around a corner, and out of sight. It looked ominously as though there might be nowhere to stand in balance along the way. But heck, five-six? What could possibly go wrong?

The face was steep! Jugs up to the traverse but I was nowhere really in balance as I struggled with protection; years before SLCDs and still longer before TriCams.

At the traverse it was a relief to see a small Chouinard angle securely placed at its outset. I clipped, called down to Sam, took a deep breath, and set out. I wasn’t half way across when I realized my arms weren’t going to hold out. I shouted “Coming back!” followed almost immediately by “Falling!” The pin held. And I got my feet out just in time to swing safely into the wall. Sam came up, took the lead, and confidently did the traverse without stopping to protect it. I followed and just barely made it to the end. I had to un-crimp my hands at the belay.

The next year, having led more sixes and a few sevens, I found myself again at “Travels,” this time with my friend and uncommonly skilled climber Steve Angelini. The idea was that this time I would successfully lead the traverse. The pin was still there but when, inevitably I fell, my feet weren’t right and I banged my knees. Steve effortlessly did the lead and I followed with difficulty.

Then, in 1980, in Dick William’s new guidebook: “Travels with Charley”, 5.8. And, in subsequent volumes: 5.7+R and even 5.8-R! I guess the pin must long be gone.

Finally, sometime in the late seventies, I was yet again passing by—looking for “Gaston” with my friend Wes Grace. Yes! There was a guy just beginning the “Travels” traverse. I touched Wes on the shoulder and said “Hey wait, watch this.” We were not disappointed.


More climbing vignettes:
Bobo to the Rescue
Serendipity
The Gendarme


 

CLimericks

With apologies to Edward Lear


Marshall’s Madness (Seneca Rocks)

         Cried Sarah, "I'm feeling right gripped!",
         As her toe, from a jam, slowly slipped.
             "This source of rope drag
             Must be a bad zag
         Produced by that zig I last clipped."           Maura Slack

Connecticut Cloudburst (Ragged Mountain)

         On the lead, when deluged from the sky,
         Sarah feared she was destined to die.
             All heard her last shout:
             "Be sure to hang out
         My slings and my Lycra to dry!"                 Paul Nylon

Bonnie’s Roof, 2nd Pitch (‘Gunks)

         As Bill traversed out past the pin
         He announced, with a sickening grin,
             "It's fifty years old
             And I can't reach the hold;
         Please notify my next of kin!"                  A. Rusty Trifle

Cathedral Concentration (New Hampshire)

         Sarah found the protection most thin.
         But, at last, an RP would slip in.
            With her mind thus at ease
            The crux seemed a breeze
         'Til she noticed she'd failed to clip in!       Hannah Solo

On the Demise of the Gendarme (Seneca Rocks, four weeks before it fell)

         Believing that sentry ill-starred,
         They crept so's to mount it un-jarred.
             No aeon knows when...
             But had it failed then
         'T would surely have caught them off guard!     Virginia West

Debonn-Air-e Show

         Went a bold mountain pilot named Walling
         To the Tetons to practice his calling.
             Rolled edgewise in flight,
             Rit shot the Gunsight
         By wielding his stick without stalling.         B. Twain Owen-Grand

Virgin Ascent (Kansas City, MO)

         When she found that the line had a lack
         Of ascent Margaret shouldered her rack,
             Donned her stealth rubber boot,
             And jammed up the route
         Which thenceforth became "Margaret's Crack".    Primo Ascenza

Sleight of Foot

         The friction climber climbs
         Where angels won't.
         Now you see him climbing...
         Now you don't.                                  Dave Bernays

Rock to Ice

         He considered bold climbing his forte,
         Until he tried cragging up norte.
             All routes now blue-icy;
             Protection way dicey.
         Thus learned him the meaning of sporte.         Sarah Waddell

Hard Hat Manque

         As she rapped off the end of her cord,
         Sarah, helmetless, laughed as she soared:
             "As I land upside down,
             Without my Joe Brown"
         They'll say "Proof that she's out of her gourd." Sarah Waddell

Filial Duty

         "On belay!" shouts Dad with a grin.
         "Climbing,", say I with chagrin.
             "This sure ain't no 'Trifle',
             (much more like the Eiffel).
         Why can't I switch with my twin?"               Matt Atkinson

Nature Study

         Some eighty-five feet in the air;
         A snake falls into my hair.
             Each handhold I seek,
             Provokes a new "Eek!"
         In each crevice a millipede's lair.             Meg Atkinson

Fraternal Love

         "Oh twin," says you "we must switch."
         "How's about you, and not I, climb this pitch?"
             "Who, me?" I reply.
             "That pitch is too high!"
         "Let elder to rope become hitched."             Gemini

The ‘Gunks of Yore: The Clean Climbing Revolution (1966-1974)

Chouinard Catalog
Chouinard Catalog (1972)

A farewell to iron:

It is little appreciated today that the completion of the protection revolution at the ‘Gunks preceded Ray Jardine’s introduction of the “Friend”—the first camming device—by about six years, the Tri-Cam by seven, and that by the time of the publication of Doug Robinson’s “The Whole Natural Art of Protection” in Chouinard’s 1972 equipment catalog it was virtually over.

In 1966 I returned to the ‘Gunks after a move from New York City to Boston and an absence from climbing of about four years. I went down with an interested friend from work and, as I drove along, I wondered whom I might greet among my old “Appie” friends at the Uberfall and whether they still hung out at Schleuter’s Mountaincrest Inn.

The changes in the area and the climbing scene were surprising and substantial. The highway had been repaved and considerably widened, permitting parking on both sides along a new metal guardrail. There were many more cars than I had remembered and, at the Uberfall, a pickup truck full of climbing gear (mostly ironmongery) was parked and presided over by one Joe Donohue who had a small business going and who collected fees for and looked out informally for the property interests of Mohonk (later the Trust, and later still, the Preserve).

GunksButtons
Often to the ‘Gunks

But what seemed most astonishing was the total disappearance of the former influence of the Appalachian Mountain Club. The Uberfall was bustling with activity but nowhere did I find a single Appie friend from four years earlier and what is more, with very few exceptions, I never, ever did. The turnover was virtually complete. Soon I made an effort to meet and establish myself with the Boston AMC climbers. Among them then: Wes Grace, Bob Chisholm, Harold Taylor, D Byers, Bob Johnson, and Bob Hall and thus began a period of many, many years of coming often to the ‘Gunks.

BrauhausThe after-climbing conviviality had moved from Schleuter’s to the bar at “Emil’s” Mountain Brauhaus at the bottom of the hill, and the comforts of the inn had given way to camping out on Clove Road just beyond the second bridge over Coxing Kill. Above some open rocky slabs there was room for tents among the trees at a place that came to be known as Wickie-Wackie after a small sign on the main road advertising a bar farther down the clove. But we gave up this area in 1970 after I had a large tent stolen. Not long after that Mohonk prohibited camping there and gave the AMC, still a more or less coherent entity, permission to use the area around a small abandoned farmhouse off US 44. For many years thereafter we crashed there at the “AMC Cabin” until the Mohonk Preserve finally reclaimed it as an historic site: the Van Leuven farm.

Mohonk had also established permission for limited tenting near the Steel Bridge in an area which came to be known affectionately as Camp Slime. Years later John Ruoff, Emil’s nephew, was horrified to learn from me that “Slime” was Emil’s spelled backward.

09091001_PitonsAlthough there was a continuing AMC presence at the cliffs the old Club restrictions were gone. One led what he felt he could negotiate safely, and confidence in the rope was increasing. Goldline still ruled in 1970 but climbers were gaining experience with the new strong and resilient kernmantle rope introduced in the fifties in Europe and which now was gradually replacing it here. By the end of the sixties slings of knotted quarter-inch Goldline had been replaced by nylon webbing, and the bowline-on-a-coil waist tie-in was giving way to safer and more comfortable home-tied Swiss seats of the same material.

Shoes had changed to designs made by climbers specifically for the sport. There were now imported RDs, PAs, and EBs eponymously initialed by their French makers: smooth rubber soles with canvas or suede tops—greatly improved over sneakers—and Kletterschuhe for edging and friction. Royal Robbin’s bright blue suede RRs (what else?) came along in 1971.

77070001_MonsterTree
The Monster Tree

At first, from the point of view of the cliffs and the protection, the climbing seemed to me pretty much as it had been in 1960; leaders carried and hammered in the occasional soft iron piton where it was deemed needed and, often as not, the second left it behind–they were hard to remove and soft iron was cheap. Resident pins tended to remain in place, as before, although some were beginning to show signs of age.

Joe Donohue had newer stuff in his truck; stuff forged by Chouinard in California and developed largely for the burgeoning aid routes in Yosemite. He stocked “angle” pitons made from hard chrome-molybdenum steel, in form like the softer sheet steel Norton Smithes of the fifties that preceded them here. The arch of the angle spread slightly, spring-like, on driving for a quick solid grip, but the grip was easily broken by a few side-to-side whacks administered by the second. Pretty easy, but–importantly–these new pins weren’t so cheap so that increasingly seconds were loath to abandon them.

Straight Lost Arrows were also of chrome-moly, stiff and more easily removed than their predecessors. Joe had thin “knife blades,” too, for fine cracks and the RURP (“Realized Ultimate Reality Piton”): a mere chip of steel for aid climbing via incipient fissures. Earlier, in 1961, Chouinard’s Bongs had arrived—the final expression of the angle concept; large pitons—some fat enough for three-inch cracks that rang with deep authority when driven: “Bong, bong!” Not long after their introduction the steel version was discontinued and replaced by light-weight hard aluminum.

The author in 1966

Gradually we updated our racks—replacing the old soft iron with the new, pricier hard stuff. My view, shared at the time by most, was to leave the occasional newly placed pin behind as a modest contribution to the general weal. Why take it out if the next one along could clip it? And so it was with shock one spring that we looked down from our stance midway up the cliff to see an approaching soloer methodically removing and racking chrome-moly. He had amassed a useful collection. It turned out to be Dick Dumais who, when challenged on this shameless lack of proper public spirit, countered that he was merely assembling his rack for an imminent trip to Yosemite.

There was, in Yosemite at first as the sixties advanced and soon at the ‘Gunks and elsewhere, a growing awareness of looming disaster—the actual destruction of the cliffs; of the cracks and small features that made climbing in any form (free or on aid) possible at all. The continued placement and removal of hard steel was having an ugly erosive effect even, we heard, on durable Yosemite granite. Piton cracks widened, even to the point where some crucial pin placement was no longer feasible. Some incipient cracks had become finger holds.

Already locally we noticed new areas of tinted rock, long protected from the elements, where a sizeable flake had been pried off from behind; large and widening pockets, especially in horizontal cracks; and a great diminution of the fixed pin protection that had been taken for granted for years.

Voices were heard in favor of reducing piton use by adopting a suspect British tradition. The Brits had a history of eschewing pitons, not so much owing to an adverse impact on the cliffs, but simply as not really very sporting. They had become used to girth hitching slings over chicken-heads and jamming sturdy knots into vertical cracks. They filled their pockets with small pebbles to be wedged like natural chock stones and slung; and those who approached their routes along railroad tracks picked up stray machine nuts for the same purpose. Later they bored out the abrasive screw threads. Thus, the “nut” was born.

But the coming revolution was as yet unforeseen.

Gear
Illustrated Nuts: 1, 2 “Nuthatches”; 3 Bong; 4 Hexcentric; 5 Stopper; 6 Titon; 7 Clog; 8 Cog

Early aluminum nuts began to appear; at first as curiosities and then gradually with suspect experimental value to augment placements where pitons weren’t feasible. Nuts manufactured specifically for climbing first appeared in England around 1961. Most resembled little Chinese take-out boxes, tapered on four sides. Others (Clogs, 1966) were made from hexagonal bar-stock cut to various lengths and drilled for bails. As the seventies dawned many variations appeared (Troll Big-Hs, Forrest Titons, Clog Cogs). Racks of pitons were more and more seen interspersed with the aluminum intruders. The small ones had braided wire bails and the large required knotted Goldline or webbing laboriously forced through the often inadequate holes provided. The wires seemed OK but the cord and webbing wanted to be as thick as possible.

Another insult was noticed. After its introduction by John Gill, gymnast’s chalk had come widely into use and some complained of the unsightly white residue left behind on once pristine and unobtrusive hand holds; although many tacitly admitted that clues were welcome as to where previous fingers in desperation had sought a home.

Piton use continued unabated. However, a consensus was building among the environmentally conscious toward the absolute necessity of abandoning reliance on them before the cliffs were chipped to pieces. The result was the “Clean Climbing” revolution.EasternTrade001The lead was taken by John Stannard (of Foops fame) as it was in the West by Royal Robbins, Tom Frost, Yvon Chouinard, and others. Stannard began the publication (1971) of a newsletter, The Eastern Trade, devoted to the conservation of the cliffs; educated climbers by taking them up the routes with nuts; and collected old steel angles to be cadmium plated, painted a distinctive gray, and placed as permanent “residents” where all agreed they were necessary. I believe that some can still be seen on the cliffs today.

Climbers “town meetings” were called and supported by Mohonk; letters written; votes taken.

And so climbers began, tentatively, reluctantly to try nuts. Very few were falling on lead and so it was a while before safe falls on nuts became common enough to begin to engender real trust. They didn’t work well in parallel-sided cracks, and especially not well in the horizontal ones that abound at the ‘Gunks.

And then, in 1971, two game-changing events occurred: the ever innovative Chouinard came out with Hexcentrics, and the All-Nut Ascents blank book appeared on the counter at Dick Williams’ (new in 1970) Rock and Snow shop in New Paltz.

Because of their eccentric “hexagonal” cross-section Hexcentrics began, sort of, to solve the problem of the horizontal crack. Rotation of the shape tended to jam it in the same way that the modern (1990) Tri-Cam does so well.

The book at Rock & Snow invited climbers duly to record “First all-nut ascents” and the result was a stampede to claim the prizes. The easy routes fell early and it was less than two years before the final, hardest routes were climbed “clean.” Actually, Royal Robbins had made the first ever recorded all-nut first ascent in Yosemite in 1966. He called it Boulderfield Gorge, although his clean 1967 Nutcracker Sweet is the one that became classic. By the end of 1972 the last open ‘Gunks route had fallen so that, at least among the skilled and the bold, the protection revolution was complete. Rock & Snow refused thereafter to stock pitons.

The next year Stannard published a list of all the new clean ascents with an additional rating: “a, b, or c” as a measure of the difficulty of protecting with nuts and fixed pins. Out of this grew today’s familiar ratings taken from the film industry.

All right then, OK for the bold, but we more timid folk were not so sure.

Stannard, Frost, and Robbins [Photo: Anders Ourom]
By this time our own tentative pure efforts had begun. I most associate this period with my climbing partners Sandy Dunlap, Tom Hayden, and Wes Grace—worthy nut-men all. We made our own “clean” ascents; my first, as I remember it, was Double Chin. “Clean” meant that we even eschewed the clipping of resident pins.

Stannard taught us how to “stack” nuts. That is, to place them in tandem with opposing tapers so that the extracting force on one caused the assembly to expand. I can remember a fascinated group at the Uberfall standing around Stannard as he worked a hydraulic jack to load a stacked set in a slightly flaring horizontal crack with an outward pull. The nylon sling gave way.

We practiced the stacking and figured out how to use two placements in opposition, each so situated as to secure the other from lifting out as the attached sling was urged upward by the moving rope, or to protect the one from being snatched in the wrong direction in a fall. We socked them in to the point where our seconds complained they couldn’t get them out. We became clever; we invited our seconds properly to admire our elegant placements before their dismantlement with the nut-pick. The pick, itself, a new development owing to the difficulty of removing jammed or hidden nuts in awkward positions, was often a homemade affair. We made picks out of kitchen spatulas and called them “nut hatches” and discovered the art of “gardening” with the pick to clean the mud and grass out of promising cracks. We mixed charcoal with chalk to dull its glaring whiteness and promoted it as “dirty chalk for clean climbing” (a lousy idea as it turned out because it sullied the beautiful, new kernmantle ropes). We modified our nuts by filing deep grooves in them and by epoxying the wire bails so that you could push on them to urge them out.

The three-nut belay anchor became our standard; we arranged equi-tension sling arrangements wherever possible.

In 1972 Chouinard came out with graded Stoppers and stacking became even easier. His improved Polycentric Hexcentrics showed up in 1974 giving us more confidence still in horizontal crack placements. Yet, we retained our doubts. For several seasons I climbed with a rigger’s energy absorption pack between my harness and the tie-in—the equivalent of the modern Screamer—it was supposed to rip three feet of stitches under a load of six-hundred pounds, but it never came to the test.

Increasingly the nuts seemed better than the pitons and, in general, placements could be found more often. Nevertheless, the 5.6 second pitch of SoB Virgin had to wait five years for the really small SLCD’s and, later, the Tri-Cam before giving up its long held reputation as a “death lead.”

Who knew that a big hex would fit the ceiling crack on Shockley’s and a smaller one go in behind the huge flake on CCK; that you could slot a perfect stopper over the bulge at the tops of High E and Madam G’s” and on the first pitch of Frog’s Head; and set a large bong endwise into the off-width on Baby? I remember getting a huge hex to stick before the desperate under-cling traverse left just off the ground on Moonlight. My first under-water hex gurgled into a solution hole on Whitehorse. When an old ring-angle pulled on Cannon it was the stopper ten feet down that saved me. And how many have clipped into the long-suffering resident wired stopper on Limelight before negotiating the delicate traverse at the top? Gradually we gained faith.

Nevertheless, while getting used to nuts, we climbed always with our hammers and a small supply of pins “just in case.” Occasionally we would clip a pin, but we had stopped placing them altogether. As Sandy recalls: “We climbed carrying pins and hammers for a long time,” until Tom said finally, “If we don’t leave the hammers behind we’ll never get any good at this.”

And so, one morning, probably around 1974, as we started out for the cliffs, I stepped back to the car, reopened the trunk and, after long hesitation, tossed my hammer into the back. I thought that it might be my last day on earth.

We survived the day; I never again climbed with a hammer at the ‘Gunks. Our own clean climbing revolution was complete.


More ‘Gunks of Yore:
The Appies


References:
For an excellent account of this period in ‘Gunks history see: Waterman & Waterman, “Yankee Rock & Ice“, Stackpole, 1993, ISBN 0-8117-1633-3, pp.193-200.

Gunks Climber’s Coalition

See also:
Tom Frost : a eulogy to an important contributor to the protection revolution.
Bernstein, Ascending”, Profiles (Chouinard), The New Yorker, January 31, 1977.
Y. Chouinard, T. Frost, “Chouinard Equipment” (catalog), Sandollar Press. 1972.
Chouinard catalog:
http://www.frostworksclimbing.com/gpiw72.html
http://climbaz.com/chouinard72/chouinard.html
Stannard, “The Eastern Trade, Vol. 0, No. 0, 1971 – Vol. 6, No. 3, 1978.
J. Middendorf: http://www.bigwalls.net/climb/mechadv/index.html
Stéphane Pennequin: https://www.needlesports.com/content/nuts-museum.aspx
Piton Antiquities: https://www.mrpiton.com/p2.htm
Richard Wanderman- Lost Arrow Spire, 1977


The ‘Gunks of Yore: The “Appies” (1956-1963)

A neophyte is hooked:

It never occurred to me that I might become a mountaineer—even though the writings of Ullman and Hunt had captivated me and, in 1939 at the age of fourteen with excitement and envy, I had seen roped teams on the glaciers and crags of Chamonix. And not in 1949, as with morbid fascination we watched, through the telescopes at Kleine Scheidegg, climbers “defying death” on the Eiger Nordwand.

Why, after all, I had none of the prerequisites. I was neither rich, nor British, nor possessed of a boyhood passed in Lederhosen in a village of the Haute-Savoie. I had not attended Harvard; my father was not a mountain guide, I hadn’t summers off from teaching. I never gave it a thought until, in 1956, I found myself at a Manhattan cocktail party in conversation with one Francis Medina who, it turned out, was a climber. A climber? Of cliffs? You’re kidding! Yes, with ropes and pitons and all? I reached out to touch him in the familiar gesture of hoi polloi toward the Gods. Where and how? The Appalachian Mountain Club? A training program for utter neophytes? He scribbled me a phone number—and my life was changed forever.

66100001_Gunks_Cliffs
The Trapps (Shockley’s Ceiling in center)

That September, having left the New York State Thruway, I drove my brand-new VW Beetle through the village of New Paltz, across the Wallkill, and out onto NY 299 headed west. What gradually rose ahead was hard to believe; an endlessly wide expanse of distant cliffs arrayed above a talus three times as high as the cliffs themselves. Wow! Who knew? There is no better introduction to this region of New York than to drive west on NY 299 on a sparkling morning.

Eventually, almost under the cliffs, I encountered a wild hairpin turn in the narrow road followed by a few cars parked on the right below a steep wooded and boulder-strewn slope. I stopped next to a pipe from which water flowed from a hidden spring.

I scrambled over the boulders to reach a private road at a climbers gathering place—the “Uberfall.” I learned further that I was in the Shawangunk (Shongum) mountains, foothills of the Catskills, and in a place which came to be known to climbers the world over as the ‘Gunks.

After having joined the AMC people (the only climbing group there), I was shown a few knots, and tied at my waist into a rope which went up thirty feet or so to a man, Cran Barrow, perched on a ledge and holding the other end. Today I’m not sure where this was but it may have been on the ledges that in recent years have become the usual descent route from the close-by climbs.

As I climbed Cran absorbed the slack. It wasn’t hard; I suppose that the “leaders” were taking notice; and I don’t remember whether I then climbed down or was lowered by the rope. Cran’s rope handling, it was explained, was “belaying.”

We few “beginners” did not belay others; not until we had become “seconds” and knew the ropes, a process requiring passage through an “intermediate” stage over a dozen or so weekends, possibly even extending into the next fall or spring season. The Club advertised weekends in the tiny AMC NY Chapter newsletter as for “Beginners,” “Intermediates,” “Leaders and seconds,” and “Leaders only.”

It surprised me that next I was taken on an ascent of the cliff—continuously in two pitches—all the way to the top. The climb was called “The Easy Overhang.” Bob Larsen, now a ranger for the Mohonk Preserve, led us up. I loved it; it was exhilarating; I was hooked.

Rather than roping up more efficiently in pairs we roped as threes because beginners were not competent to belay and because the terrain was not amenable to top-roping.

In a few weeks they classified me as “Intermediate” which opened up the weekends for which I was eligible to register. We drove up on Saturday mornings to meet at the Uberfall. I went as often as possible, gradually getting to know the others on climbs, during the two-hour carpooling from Manhattan, and relaxing at day’s end around the bar at Schleuter’s Mountaincrest Inn where we stayed.

The inn was a kind of bed-and-breakfast on NY 44 a mile or so south of the present Mountain Brauhaus. Dinner followed “Happy Hour,” and often members showed slides or offered instructional lectures. The inn served breakfast and I think one could order a box lunch for Sunday. The Club kept its ropes and equipment in Schleuter’s basement.

The AMC was the sole organizing entity at the cliffs and, until the late fifties, pretty much oversaw all climbing activities. They supervised with what some others had begun to feel as an unwonted obsession with safety procedures—an understandable outgrowth of the fallout from a fatal AMC accident at Arden, NY in 1940. Parties signed out for climbs and signed back in upon returning safely. The Club trained and the Qualifying Committee approved its leaders and ranked them by experience and ability as “all fours,” “all fives,” or “unlimited” leaders.

56100707_Gunks_FrgHd
Fred Saxe on Frog’s Head (1956)

Increasingly the Club viewed, with suspicion and some hostility, unapproved leaders from other, especially unfamiliar, groups who had begun to increase in number. College outing clubs such as those from CCNY, Columbia, Yale, Harvard, Syracuse, and the University of Pennsylvania showed up occasionally and increasingly put unwonted pressure on the AMC hegemony.

Friction gradually developed between the “Appies,” the self-appointed arbiters of safety and standards, and the outliers who chafed at the notion of restriction and formality. The AMC felt responsibility to the property owners and looked with suspicion upon the activities of those exploring new and more dangerous territory. A rift opened which culminated in the coalescence of a group of bold and skilled climbers under the rubric of the “Vulgarian Mountain Club,” and the history of their press into the realms of higher standards of difficulty, and of their raucous crusade to shock Appie sensibility, became legend.

Bob Larsen, who took me up many of my first climbs, had a foot in each world: he held a rating of “unlimited leader” with the Club; I smoked my first joint in his East Village apartment.

57052603(2)_Gunks_Shckly_BT
Shockley’s (Bob Chambers, Barney Toerin, Harris Tallan)

The leaders I remember included Hans Kraus, Bob Larsen, Bonnie Prudden, Kristin and Wally Raubenheimer, Bob Jones, Fred Saxe, Ted Church, Mary Sylvander, Bob Chambers, Barney Toerien, and Ira Schnell among others. The proportion of engineers and physicists was high. Bell Labs fielded William Shockley (the transistor) and Lester Germer (electron diffraction). Jones and Barrow worked at PerkinElmer (space optics) and IBM in Poughkeepsie was well represented. Cran Barrow and then Norton Smithe were the Safety Committee chairs of the time.

Climbing routes had difficulty ratings, e.g., “easy four,” “five,” “hard five,” etc.; outgrowths of the early European categories: 1 through 6. “The Easy Overhang,” for example, was an “easy four” (4), “Gelsa” a 4+, and “High Exposure” a 5. The Yosemite Decimal System arrived around 1960. The “Appies” repertoire included a group of some six dozen routes in the Trapps, Near Trapps, and at Sky Top pioneered in the ’40s and ’50s, and most within the rating “5+” which today would probably include all (Yosemite) 5.6s and some 5.7s.

57052601_Gunks_AGran
Uberfall- Art Gran (in beret)

People talked about guides to the routes and it fell eventually to Art Gran to write the first bound and published guidebook (1964). The old-timers had the routes firmly established in memory and we lesser folk walked the Carriage Road poring over dog-eared handwritten and typewritten lists of the climbs arranged in order down the cliff.

In this period, largely in the background and to some extent outside the sphere of the AMC, harder routes fell to the bold, and by the early sixties 5.8 and 5.9 routes had become relatively common and 5.10 had been established. Some of the familiar names associated with this expanding period are those of Jim McCarthy, Jim Andress, Dave Craft, Dick Williams, Art Gran, and Will Crowther.

56102804_Gunks_Layback
Layback– Bob Larsen & Ellis Blade

In the warm weather we swam in Awosting Creek at a lovely cascade downstream of the falls and across route 44/55 on what is now Minnewaska property. The ‘Gunks were generally abandoned in the summer as most went West or elsewhere. I went up once with some visiting friends only to find that we were the only party at the cliffs. That first summer I went to the Tetons where I was able to scale the East Ridge of the Grand with Philip Gribbon of the Irish Mountaineering Club.

Belaying was much discussed. The approved maneuver was the “body” belay—friction devices had yet to appear. As a result of WWII research for the Tenth Mountain Division laid (twisted) nylon (Goldline, Perlon) mountaineering ropes had become universally available—replacing Manila hemp—the pre-war standard. Because of the known elastic limitations of hemp to contain high energy falls the mountaineering community had earlier developed strong views concerning the use of the rope for the purpose of security. Because hemp could not contain the fall of a leader Geoffrey Winthrop Young’s dictum “The leader does not fall” universally prevailed. The rope was carried only to secure the second.

57052608_Gunks_Shckly_MM
Marianne Marquardt on Shockley’s Ceiling

Not enough was yet known about the new, obviously stronger and more elastic, nylon to allay the inherent fear of the leader fall. A fear that contributed strongly to the conservatism of the period, and which begat endless discussions and calculations about the need for the “dynamic” belay as a necessary means to reduce dangerous forces on rope, piton, and climber. To my knowledge, before and during my early years at the ‘Gunks, no AMC qualified leader had ever fallen.

Although the cliffs occupied the private property of the Mohonk Mountain House, the hotel had no presence at the cliffs. After about 1960 the management asked for fees from the Club to cover changes in insurance but there were never rangers or officials in evidence at the Uberfall.

56111701_Gunks_Gatehouse
Mohonk Main Gate

In the late fall and early spring the Raubenheimers would organize a weekend at the Mountain House when the hotel was closed for the season; host to a boy’s school. The Smiley family, Quakers, owned and ran the hotel. Limousines would meet us at the architecturally fanciful Gatehouse on NY 299 and spirit us to Sky Top for a day of climbing followed by set-ups (no liquor in the public spaces) in our private rooms (each with a working fireplace), dinner in the main dining hall (no smoking), and a box lunch for Sunday.

I remember one snowy morning at Skytop; Walley Raubenheimer and some others were rolling huge wet snowballs on the Gargoyle ledge and sending them down upon us below.

56111708_Gunks_SnowballsWe climbed in sneakers—although stiffer soled shoes, suede leather “Kletterschuhe” better for edging, had begun to appear from Europe. We tied into the rope around the waist with a bowline-on-a-coil. The addition of a hammer, a few carabiners, and a pin or two made the sole difference in equipment between the leader and his second–the hammer to test the safe “ring” of the fixed pins and the ‘biners to clip the rope into the pitons along the way and at the belay stances. When capped by a small overhang the piton was strung with a chain of ‘biners to prevent binding of the rope. No leader protection existed between fixed pins unless he drove another, which was not common. On the positive side a “rack” didn’t weigh much.

A first ascent party placed pitons where it deemed them necessary and left them in place—the soft-iron was cheap and, at the same time, often difficult to remove. The pins served both to mark the route and to cement the claim of “first.”

56100701_Gunks_FrgHd
Frog’s Head– Fred Saxe

Aluminum carabiners, produced by Yosemite’s Raffi Bedayn, had just arrived to replace their heavier steel predecessors. Carabiners, forged soft-iron pitons from Europe, hammers, and rope could be purchased at Camp and Trail on Canal Street—Manhattan’s only mountaineering equipment store, other than Midtown’s tony Abercrombie and Fitch. It was not long after the arrival of the Bedayn ‘biner that its virtue as a beer cap opener was discovered.

To complete the picture there were no special shoes; no slings (quick-draws); no nylon webbing, no harnesses other than self made “Swiss seats”; no Sticht plates, ATCs, or figure-eights; no helmets; no chalk; and no protection devices of any kind. Because of the lurking fear of a leader fall belayers usually wore gloves knowing for certain that in an emergency the rope would run.

In truth, toward the end of this period, slings of doubled and knotted quarter-inch Goldline made an appearance, but it was not until the sixties that nylon webbing and kernmantle rope showed up.

The lack of friction devices laid hardship on the rappeller who descended the rope using a Dulfersitz or body rappel. We all had to demonstrate an ability to do this and many had jackets and knee-pants with reinforced shoulders and crotch. No one mentioned methods for freeing the hands in mid-descent as is now common.

56100709_Gunks_Gelsa
Kristin Raubenheimer on Gelsa (1956)

Eventually a so-called “brake-bar” appeared which, when laid across the width of a ‘biner, could act as a crude friction device.

We climbed always all the way to the top of the cliff and walked back to the Uberfall along a well-worn trail; a trail that today is almost obliterated by nature because “rapping” down has become almost universal. The last bit of the scramble down required an “uberfall” by which one crossed a disconcertingly wide gap using an upper-body fall, arrested by the hands on the opposite wall, and followed by a long step across the void. Today’s climbers hardly know of this way down.

After having climbed as an “Intermediate” for a season one became eligible to become a “Second” after having demonstrated a knowledge of knots and having passed the belay test–the successful arresting on belay of a heavy weight set up on a timber projecting out from the cliff in the corner to the right of “Boston“. Having passed this hurdle one could combine with leaders to take beginners on the rope. The next step: getting a “leg on a climb”.

One day in the spring of 1957 below the top pitch of “Baby” Bob Larsen asked whether I would lead the next pitch. Well. OK, I guess so. I knew there was a hard, thin move in the corner about halfway up and a strenuous bit at the end. Bob handed me a couple of ‘biners to augment my few—by then I had a hammer—and without too much “Sturm und Drang” I made it up the corner and over the top. I had just gotten my first “leg on a climb” from an AMC “qualifying” leader.

That fall, a year after my first climb and after having amassed some number of “legs” from other leaders, I was told that the Qualifying Committee had voted me permission to lead “all fours”.

After 1958, owing to marriage and children, my ‘Gunks climbing tapered off, ending in a move to Boston in 1963. Whether I had reached the leading of “all fives” I do not remember. But by the time I returned to the ‘Gunks in 1966 the question had become moot inasmuch as the Appies were no longer dominant at the cliffs.


Postscript: The ‘Gunks of Yore (of Yore)

In the latter part of the nineteenth century my grandfather, a professor of Civil Engineering at Cornell University, generally spent several summer weeks vacationing at Minnewaska’s Cliff House often accompanied by his daughter, my mother (Elsie Sterling Church), who took this photograph at the Trapps more than a hundred years ago:

1914-3_UndClfRd
The Trapps (ca. 1910)


More ‘Gunks of Yore:
The Clean Climbing Revolution


References:
From Steve Jervis:
Steve’s webpage
http://stevenjervis.com/Gunksarticle.pdf
And from Louise (Andress) Trancynger:
Gardiner Gazette 11, pp. 4-5 (no longer available) and
Gardiner Gazette 12, pp. 4-5 (no longer available) (page 4 is missing)

A wonderful discovery of an 1955 AMC NY Chapter address book (courtesy Steve Jervis)
And, in addition, I remember Barney Toerien, Alex Hahoutoff, the Reeses, the Elricks, Ira Schnell, Bill Cropper, Fred Lazarus. . .

For an excellent account of this period in ‘Gunks history see:
Waterman & Waterman, Yankee Rock & Ice, Stackpole, 1993, ISBN 0-8117-1633-3, pp. 133-147, 154-163.
Also: “Ungentlemanly Behavior” an historical piece by Chris Jones, Climbing in North America, pg. 213ff, (AAC), University of California Press, Berkley, 1976.
And: Victoria Robinson, Rock Climbing—The Ultimate Guide, Origins, p.33, p-36-39, Greenwood, 2013.
“How I met the Vulgarians” , John Stannard.

The definitive (rare!) guidebook of the period:
Arthur Gran, A Climber’s Guide to the Shawangunks AAC/AMC, 1964.
My copy was once found with a broken spine in the middle of NY Route 55 and returned to me by Bill Putnam, who wryly observed that I was off route.

From SuperTopo:
Pre-1964 ‘Gunks guidebooks, Crowther, Ingalls, etc..

For a look into the ferment surrounding ropes and belaying see:
Arnold Wexler, The Theory of Belaying, AAJ Vol. VII, No 4 (1950)
Hassler Whitney, Fred Beckey, Belaying, AAJ, Accidents Alpina, 1951
Leonard, Wexler, et al, Belaying the Leader, Sierra Club, 1956.

Gunks Climber’s Coalition